Kolkata Knight Riders (KKR) have come under scrutiny after their IPL 2025 opening match defeat to Royal Challengers Bangalore (RCB). Critics argue that KKR lost their home advantage due to an unsupportive pitch at Eden Gardens. However, the stadium’s curator, Sujan Mukherjee, has dismissed these claims, stating that the pitch was prepared according to Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) guidelines. In this article, we explore Mukherjee’s response, KKR’s concerns, and whether the pitch played a role in their defeat.
Did KKR Lose Their Home Advantage?
After KKR’s loss to RCB, questions were raised about the Eden Gardens pitch. Many expected it to favor spinners, given KKR’s strong spin-bowling attack. However, the pitch conditions did not seem to provide the home team with the expected advantage. This led to speculation that the pitch was not prepared in a way that suited KKR’s playing style.
Curator Sujan Mukherjee has denied these accusations, stating that he followed all BCCI regulations and did not receive any special requests from KKR. He made it clear that as long as he is in charge, the pitch will be maintained fairly and independently, without any external influence.
Curator’s Response: Pitch Was Prepared Fairly
Mukherjee defended his work, emphasizing that no KKR players or officials approached him with specific pitch requirements. He stated:
“As long as I’m here, the Eden Gardens pitch will not change. As per IPL rules and regulations, franchises have no say over the pitch.”
This statement highlights that pitch preparation is not under the control of IPL teams but rather follows league-wide standards. Mukherjee also pointed out that Eden Gardens has maintained consistent pitch conditions over the years, regardless of the home team’s strengths.
Did KKR Bowlers Fail to Utilize the Pitch?
Mukherjee further argued that the issue wasn’t with the pitch but rather with KKR’s bowling performance. He noted that RCB’s spinners took four wickets, showing that the conditions were useful for spin bowling. However, KKR’s spinners failed to capitalize on the same pitch.
“Ever since I have taken charge, the pitches here have been like this. RCB spinners took four wickets between them. What did the KKR spinners do?”
His comments suggest that KKR’s loss was due to their bowlers’ inability to adapt to the conditions rather than any disadvantage caused by the pitch.
While some critics claim that KKR lost their home advantage, Eden Gardens curator Sujan Mukherjee insists that the pitch was fair and prepared according to BCCI regulations. His argument that RCB’s spinners succeeded while KKR’s struggled raises questions about KKR’s performance rather than the pitch itself. Regardless of the debate, one thing is clear—teams must adapt to conditions rather than rely solely on home advantage.
Visit Home